Operators who handle product or freight (3PLs, warehouses, cold storage, co-packers, carriers, brokers, forwarders, cross-docks) and service providers (software, marketplace and marketing agencies, customs brokers, consultants, finance and insurance, staffing, packaging, sourcing). One process, the same bar.
Getting in
- Application and disclosure screenOwnership, years operating, facilities or headcount, volumes or client count, certifications and platforms, systems, insurance, client concentration, and anything pending: litigation, a sale, an insurance lapse. Commission terms accepted up front. Incomplete disclosures and hard-stop answers are declined automatically.
- Document reviewOverview deck, certificate of insurance, and what the category demands: FDA registration, SQF or BRCGS, ISO, C-TPAT or hazmat for operators; SOC 2 or a completed security questionnaire for software; licences and bonds for customs brokers, lenders and insurers; platform partner status for marketplace and advertising agencies. A sample contract or statement of work with the full rate card or pricing, at least one case study or success example per vertical served, and the performance reporting that proves the KPIs claimed. We read the rate card specifically for accessorials that never appear in a quote.
- Five client references, calledCalled by us, with a standard question set. The five should include current clients, one onboarded recently, one who went through a peak season or scaled with them, and one former client or a client who downsized. If they cannot name a former client we ask why. We ask about invoices versus quotes, results against what was promised, who actually did the work after the sale, what went wrong and how it was handled, response time when something broke, and whether they would sign again.
- Leadership interviewC-suite executives plus the operations and business development teams, and for service providers the delivery or customer success lead, in person where possible. Capacity plan for the next twelve months, client concentration, labor model, team tenure and turnover, churn in the last twelve months and the honest reasons for it, who they turn away and why, their worst month in the last two years and what they did about it, ownership intentions. We are listening for candor as much as for answers.
- In-person visit, or a live working sessionOperators: an in-person visit to every facility, during a live shift. We walk receiving, put-away, pick, pack, returns and the dock, watching the work done at pace, and we meet the site leadership, the account team who would run a client day to day, and the floor: the leads and associates who will handle the product. We ask them how a mis-pick is caught, what happens when a carrier misses a pickup, and how a new client's SKUs get set up; their answers tell us whether the SOPs are real. We check scan validation at pick and pack, cycle-count cadence, housekeeping and safety, access control, temperature zones and monitoring where applicable, and the WMS and RF tools actually in use. Service providers, who have no floor to walk: a live working session with the team you would actually get, in person where possible. Software runs a real workflow on its production instance with the implementation and support people who would be assigned; agencies walk a live client account and its results with the team that runs it; brokers, finance and staffing verify licences and bonds and walk a sample file or placement end to end. Not a slide deck, not the sales team.
- Scorecard decisionTen weighted dimensions, filled in by the person who made the calls and did the visit: capability, execution evidence, people and leadership, systems and data, commercial transparency, financial stability and insurance, integrity and candor, market and vertical depth, client experience and responsiveness, and scalability and capacity. Three outcomes: admitted; admitted with conditions, with named items to fix before the first introduction and a re-check inside 90 days; or declined, with reasons, and welcome to reapply after twelve months.
- Partner agreement and profile buildCommission terms, a bill-as-quoted or price-as-quoted commitment, SLA disclosures, a named account lead, reference permission, and an agreed statement of what they are not a fit for. The profile goes live only after the agreement is signed.
Staying in
- Monthly client check-insEvery month we hear directly from the clients each partner serves: live feedback on billing versus quote, responsiveness, service levels and how onboarding went. That feedback feeds the rating every partner and vendor carries in the network, so a strong month shows, and a bad one does too.
- Quarterly business review and profile updateEvery quarter, every partner and vendor. Leadership and account management review introductions received, conversion, client feedback, open issues and growth plans, and the partner updates its profile: capabilities, capacity and volumes, headcount, certifications and licenses, systems and pricing structure. Profiles that are not updated are paused from new introductions until they are.
- Annual in-person visit and re-scoringOperators: we walk every facility again, during a live shift, with the same questions as admission. Service providers: a fresh working session on a live product or client account, plus refreshed security, licence and insurance documents. Every visit ends with the ten-dimension scorecard re-scored in house and combined with the year of client feedback. That score sets the partner's rating and standing in the network for the year ahead.
- Probation and removalProbation: a client complaint about billing, service level or communication not resolved within 30 days, a drop in a tracked metric, or a lapsed certification. Removal, immediately: misrepresentation on the application or in references, billing materially different from the quote, an insurance lapse, or treating a SurgeSteer client as a lead to be sold around us. Removed partners are told why.